Buyer's Guides

The Best Toastie Makers for Cafe-standard Toasties

Whip up crisp, juicy, and delicious toasties with Australia’s top-rated toastie makers. 🥪 🧑‍🍳
Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr

The best toastie maker can dramatically change how you make your toasties. Additionally, they are easy to use and will allow you to prepare your favourite toastie recipes within the shortest time possible. Most toastie makers have adjustable temperature settings that will help you cook the bread and fillings with precision.

A good toastie maker won’t spill the cheese, and neither will it leave untoasted patches. But most importantly, these appliances ensure the fillings are nicely cooked without burning the bread. Plus, some models are fitted with removable cooking plates that you can swap according to your toasting needs.

TL;DR: The #1 Sandwich and Toastie Maker for Most People 👇

Price reduction
Breville The Original 74 Sandwich Maker
84 Reviews
Breville The Original 74 Sandwich Maker

Simple yet efficient—the Original ’74 has all the features that one may look for in a toastie maker. The edges of the heating plates are moulded to ensure you get nicely sealed toasties, so the fillings won’t spill all over the place.

It boasts a scissor action functionality that will provide you with clean cuts on each toastie that you will make!!

However, the market is not deficient in toastie makers as there are countless brands out there that sell these units. As such, finding a sandwich maker that fits your budget, requirements, and quality standards could prove challenging. To give you a helping hand, we have listed six of the best sandwich and toastie makers that you can buy in Australia.

Use the links below to skip to a toastie maker of your choosing:

The Best Sandwich and Toastie Makers to Buy Today in Australia

1. Breville The Original 74 Sandwich Maker (Best for Most People)

Price reduction
84 Reviews

Why we like it:
  • Straightforward design
  • Easy to clean
  • It cuts and seals toasties
What customers say:

“They just don’t make them like this version anymore. This is the original and the best toasted sandwich maker on the market. Worth the spend!” –Karen

Our top pick for the best sandwich and toastie makers is the Breville The Original 74 Sandwich Maker due to its impressive scissor action feature, durable construction, and easy-clean design. And as the name implies, this model is a reinvention of the original jaffle maker that was first designed in 1974 by Breville.

What we liked most about this unit is that it is easy to use. It is super-efficient and has great features that will help you take your jaffle-making skills a notch higher. This appliance will not only grill your toasties but also seal them, meaning the fillings will remain between the two pieces of bread throughout the toasting process. Plus, the high-power heating element generates just enough heat to cook the fillings without charring the bread.

The Original ’74 preheats quickly, so it won’t keep you waiting when you are famished. Furthermore, it has both temperature-ready and power indicator lights. The former lights up when the cooking plates have been heated to the optimum level, while the latter lets the user know if the unit is heating. To make it even better, the lights are strategically placed atop the upper housing for easy viewing. Also, the pockets are generously sized, so the bread won’t get squashed when you close the top.

On top of that, the upper plates have thin diagonally-placed protrusions that deliver scissor-like action, allowing you to cut the toasties into two triangle halves. Each toastie will come out with grill marks, making them look even more appetizing. This toastie maker can make two jaffles simultaneously. Even though the plates are not removable, they are designed in such a way that you can easily wipe them down with a damp cloth after each use.

The long stay-cool handles will allow you close or open the top without burning your hands. And since there is a locking latch on the lower handle, this jaffle maker will stay closed, thereby preventing heat loss when the jaffles are cooking. To top it all up, this toastie maker is made of stainless steel for enhanced durability. You should, however, keep in mind that the Original ’74 doesn’t come cheap. On the bright side, this is a unit that you can fully count on when it comes to making tasty, perfectly cooked jaffles.

Pros
  • Non-stick plates

  • Compact design

  • Non-slip feet

Cons
  • The plates are not as deep, so you can’t put extra fillings between bread slices

2. ‎Belaco BS-107S (Best Sandwich Toaster for Small Kitchens)

165 Reviews

Why we like it:
  • Interlocking handles
  • Space-saving design
  • Cool-touch handle
What customers say:

“Easy to use cleans easily and seals in flavour.” –SYLVIA MCCAW

We highly recommend the Belaco BS-107S Maker, Panini Press, Sandwich Toaster for users who have limited space in their kitchen. It has a compact design, thus making it easy to store. Additionally, it won’t take up a lot of space on your kitchen counter. Like the first toastie maker on the list, this unit has two indicator lights that will make your work easier when making toasties.

The interlocking handles will ensure the slices of bread stay in place when the top is closed. Both the upper and lower plates have a non-stick coating that allows for quick and effortless cleaning. The 750-watt heating element dissipates heat uniformly, so your toasties will cook evenly. Nonetheless, the plates only measure 12cm by 22cm and may limit you from using large slices of bread.

You will also have to minimize the amount of filling because the pockets are rather shallow. With the right slices of bread, you can make two toasties at a go. The Belaco BS-107S will help you get the job done in less than five minutes. All the parts are firmly attached to the plastic casing, so the unit won’t fall apart even when put to everyday use. The housing stays cool, so the plastic material won’t melt during usage.

The Belaco BS-107S has a centrally placed hinge that allows the top and lower plates to align uniformly when the unit is closed. As such, the heat won’t escape during the cooking process. This means the fillings and bread slices will cook to the desired level without leaving any untoasted patches. But that is not all; this sandwich toaster weighs approximately ‎1.1 kilograms, allowing for easy portability.

If you don’t mind making small toasties, this may just be the right product for you. It preheats very fast and is also safe for users. One of its limitations is that it cannot make thick toasties. Stuffing the slices of bread with too much filling can prevent the lid from closing properly, as noted by most users.

Pros
  • Temperature ready indicator lights

  • Ultra-lightweight

  • Easy to operate

Cons
  • It may be too small for most people

3. Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 (Best Multi-use Sandwich and Toastie Maker)

Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 Multi-Function Sandwich and Snack Maker
59 Reviews
Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 Multi-Function Sandwich and Snack Maker

Why we like it:
  • Removable non-stick plates
  • Versatile
  • Durably built
What customers say:

“Came with 2 plates, one to make toasties and another to make waffles. Very convenient and works wonderfully.” –Camilo

If you are after versatility, look no further than the Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 Multi-Function Sandwich and Snack Maker. This unit is more than a toastie maker. It has interchangeable plates that will allow you to make waffles, wafers, paninis, bricelets, pancakes, etc. However, it only comes with two plates—for making toasties and waffles, so you will have to buy the other plates separately.

Swapping plates is very easy and will only take a few seconds of your time. Moreover, you can attach or remove the plates without using any tool. With this toastie maker, you can make a variety of snacks in the comfort of your home. The heating element on this unit has a wattage rating of 700W, which is great for cooking sandwiches and toasties. Like most toastie makers in its class, the Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 has a ready-to-cook indicator light for user convenience.

The included plates are not only non-stick but also dishwasher safe. With that said, you can rinse off greasy stains without breaking a sweat. Attached to the upper housing is a cool-to-touch handle that is ergonomically designed to increase user comfort. The locking mechanism seals the unit shut, thereby allowing the toasties to cook at a consistent temperature. Aside from having a sturdily built base, this unit is fitted with non-slip feet.

This jaffle maker has a simple design and is, therefore, a suitable option for all users. The plates are 22.5cm x 13.5cm and can accommodate standard size slices of bread. You won’t have to worry about the plates squashing the toasties because each pocket is shaped to a favourable depth. Still, ensure that you don’t use excess fillings. What’s more, the edges of the toasties will be sealed, thus preventing the contents from spilling out.

One of the things that we liked most about the Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 is that it is made of high-quality stainless steel. Also, the hinge glides smoothly, so you won’t have to exert a lot of effort when closing or opening the top. It is also not as heavy despite its heavy-duty construction. The only disadvantage of this sandwich maker is that it is not easy to find the extra plates.

Pros
  • Very efficient

  • Great quality

  • Multifunctional

Cons
  • You only get two plates

4. Breville ‎LTS425GRY (Best Sandwich Maker for Large Families)

Price reduction
71 Reviews

Why we like it:
  • Count-down timer
  • Innovatively designed
  • High power heating element
What customers say:

“This Brewille Sandwich Maker is built like a tank. It is big but works very well. Storage could be a problem in small kitchens.” –LuisK

The Breville Sandwich Makers is one of the best 4 slice models that you can consider buying. This unit may be fourth on the list, but it has amazing features that put it a step ahead of the first three toastie makers on our list. For starters, it has a convenient timer function that allows you to cook jaffles according to your preference. You can also make use of the ‘A Bit More’ function for extra crispy toasties.

And since it can make up to four toasties at the same time, it can be a suitable option for large families. This unit heats up quickly, thanks to its 2,000-watt heating element. All four slots receive an equal amount of heat, so none of the toasties will be burnt. The fact that it is high-powered means your jaffles will cook fast. To add to this, the control panel has a user-friendly design and will provide you with a frustration-free toasting experience.

This jaffle maker is similar to the Original ’74 in that both can automatically seal and cut the jaffles with precision. The lid has a handle that is conveniently curved upwards for easy accessibility. Like all toastie makers from Breville, this appliance is built from premium-grade materials to ensure you get a unit that is both functional and durable. It also has an auto-shutoff function for increased user safety.

The easy-to-use locking latch will keep the lid shut whilst the toasties are cooking. That way, the fillings will be properly cooked at the right temperature, while the bread will brown to your liking. Simply set the timer depending on the type of fillings that you are using, and let the machine do the rest. It is important to keep in mind that some fillings may require more time to cook while others can be ready in just a few minutes.

You can easily clean the plates by wiping them down using a soft piece of cloth. It is recommended that you clean the plates after they have cooled down to avoid burning yourself. This sandwich maker is slightly larger compared to most models that we have reviewed, measuring 36 cm x 31.2cm x 12.8cm (L x W x H). So ensure that you have enough storage space.

Pros
  • The plates deliver clean cuts

  • Lockable lid

  • Quad size

Cons
  • Takes up more counter space compared to most models on our review list

5. Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED (Best Sandwich and Toastie Maker for Extra Fillings)

Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwhich Press
203 Reviews
Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwhich Press

Why we like it:
  • Floating hinge design
  • Vertical storage
  • Stainless steel construction
What customers say:

“No problems at all. No “cold spots” yet and have used it extensively since purchased. Perfect result every time and just wipe clean with paper towels.” –Aussie Rick

Featuring a 2,100-watt heating element, the Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwich Press can help you make cafe-grade toasties without giving you any problem. This toastie maker has a large capacity and will allow you to make enough toasties for the whole family. Like the Breville ‎LTS425GRY, it can make four toasties concurrently.

Plus, the heating zone is coated to prevent the bread from sticking onto the surface of the plates. The standout feature of this toastie maker is the floating hinge. It allows you to make toasties of varying thicknesses. Apart from that, the hinge ensures the upper and lower plates are perfectly aligned, allowing for equal heat distribution. You can also use extra fillings to get the desired taste.

Nonetheless, you shouldn’t use too much cheese when making cheese toasties since some of it may spill out after it has melted. Unlike most toastie makers on the market, this unit has flat cooking plates, making it even easier to clean. It has a large handle that will give you full control over the lid when accessing the heating plates. There is a locking mechanism on the side that keeps the unit closed during storage.

And because it folds down neatly, it won’t take up a lot of space, especially when you place it in a vertical position. This equipment has well-designed feet that offer maximum stability. The Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED will cook your toasties in about four minutes. Nevertheless, this may vary depending on the thickness of the bread and the amount of filling that you are using.

The good thing about this sandwich maker is that it can accommodate virtually all slices of bread. It comes in two colours, so you can go for this model (red) or the silver option. The flaws; this unit does not seal the toasties, so it can create a mess if proper care is not taken. Additionally, it does not cut the toasties. All in all, it is sturdily built, efficient, easy to use, and will provide you with quality service.

Pros
  • Built to last

  • Plates are non-stick

  • Multi-use

Cons
  • The plates are not removable

6. Breville BTS100SIL The Big One (Best Value Sandwich Maker)

Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwhich Press
203 Reviews
Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwhich Press

Why we like it:
  • Extra-large heating plates
  • Deep pockets
  • Sealing function
What customers say:

“Desirable brand. Good value and this does work very well with no sticking issues at all. Extremely easy to clean and toasts evenly. Highly recommended.” –RMS

The Breville BTS100SIL The Big One Sandwich Maker is yet another high-quality model that you can add to your kitchen. It has deep pockets that allow you to stuff the slices of bread with more fillings. This is a two-slice toastie maker and is specially designed to help you make large jaffles.

The jaffles won’t stick onto the heating plates because the surfaces are coated. This feature also allows for easy cleaning, so you won’t have a hard time getting rid of the grease. The edges of the pates are ingeniously moulded to allow for easy sealing. As a result, the contents of your sandwich won’t spill out even when using a lot of filling. And like the two models from Breville that we looked at earlier, the BTS100SIL is fitted with red and green indicator lights.

The green light will notify you when the heating element has achieved the required cooking temperature. On the other hand, the red one indicates the unit is properly connected and is heating as it should. This jaffle maker is aesthetically designed, so rest assured it will look great on your kitchen countertop. And although it doesn’t have a timer like the Breville ‎LTS425GRY, this unit will cook your jaffles to the level that you want.

Also, the jumbo-sized heating plates are made of high-quality cast aluminium to increase heat dissipation. The housing is built from plastic, but that does not mean that it is less durable. It is heavily reinforced to prevent breakage. But most importantly, it stays cool, so you won’t get burnt. On the downside, this particular model does not deliver the scissor action like the Original ’74, so it won’t cut the jaffle in half.

Pros
  • Quick heat up

  • Non-stick heating plates

  • Very easy to clean

Cons
  • There have been complaints about the PFOA-free coating peeling

How We Researched the Best Sandwich and Toastie Makers

To come up with this list, we chose products based on independent customer reviews and ratings on renowned e-commerce marketplaces in Australia like Myer, Amazon, eBay, Target, and The Good Guys. Our editorial team found a long list of products with good reviews, so we had to do head-to-head comparisons to find the best toastie makers.

We compared the products based on size and depth of cooking plates, ease of use, user safety, and toasting speed. In addition to this, we visited ProductReview.com.au. As a result, we were able to identify the key features that most people look for in toastie makers. Appliances that were lacking the important features we removed from the list, leaving us with ten toastie makers.

In the last phase of our selection process, we compared major brands that are known for selling high-quality sandwich makers in the Australian market. This made it easy to eliminate toastie makers that did not meet the just mentioned criteria. By the time we were done, we only had six products, which were properly reviewed to give you this guide.

Sandwich & Toastie Makers: Buying Guide

There are key things that you should take into account before spending on a toastie maker. Also, always keep in mind that not all sandwich makers are made equal. Manufacturers have different ways of making these appliances, and all claim to be the best. With that said, it is your responsibility as the consumer to ensure the product that you are buying is not only legit but also of high quality.

As highlighted at the beginning of this article, choosing a toastie maker is no easy task since there are so many things that you have to consider. Doing the research work is both time-consuming and exhausting. To make your work easier, you can use this buying guide when sourcing for a toastie maker. We have tried our best to include every bit of information that you may need when shopping for these appliances.

What to Consider When Buying Sandwich and Toastie Makers

Build quality

Toastie makers are made of a variety of materials. However, most of these units have plastic outer casings, while others feature stainless steel construction. The latter is more durable and also costs more. This is not to say that plastic toastie makers are not reliable.

Nonetheless, if you were to compare the two in terms of durability, the steel-built models will come out victorious. The good news is that some plastic models offer almost the same level of durability as their stainless steel counterparts, so ensure that you choose wisely based on your budget.

Capacity

Sandwich and toastie makers vary when it comes to capacity and overall size. You can go for a four-slice or two-slice model depending on your needs. If you know that you will be making toasties for multiple people, you should consider buying larger models since they’ll help you prep multiple servings at a go.

You should also factor in the overall size of the appliance. This will help you determine whether the space on your countertop can accommodate the unit that you want to buy.

Price

The price of a toastie maker in Australia can range from $35 to $300.However, some models come at a cheaper price or may cost more. If you are on a tight budget, you can buy affordable models. The capacity of the toastie maker also determines the price.

Ease of cleaning

Hygiene is of utmost importance when in the kitchen. As such, it is recommended that you go for appliances that are easy to clean. Most toastie makers can be cleaned by wiping down the greasy plates using a soft damp cloth. Nevertheless, some models have removable cooking plates that are dishwasher safe.

User safety

Your safety should top your list of concerns when buying any electrical appliance. And given that toastie makers generate heat, you should even be more careful.

When buying a toastie maker, you should purchase one that has indicator lights that can let you know when the cooking plates are temperature-ready. This will safeguard your hands against burns.

Best Brands That Sell Sandwich & Toastie Makers in Australia

Breville

Founded in 1932, Breville is an Australian company that is known for making high-quality household appliances. The company has won over forty design awards internationally and is also rated the best brand for sandwich and toastie makers in Australia by Canstar Blue.

As a matter of fact, the first sandwich toaster was created by Breville in 1974, making it one of the reliable brands that you can go for when buying toastie makers. Moreover, the brand offers different types of toastie makers that you can choose from.

We have covered three models of sandwich makers in our review list, so you can go for the Breville The Original 74 Sandwich Maker, Breville Sandwich Makers, or Breville BTS100SIL The Big One Sandwich Maker.

Russel Hobbs

Russel Hobbs is a UK-based company, but it has remained one of the top-tier home appliance companies in Australia. Like Breville, Russel Hobbs is a reputable brand that you can fully count on when shopping for sandwich and toastie makers.

The Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwich Press can be a great pick if you are looking for a toastie maker from this brand.

Tefal

Tefal makes great kitchenware products and can provide you with high-performance toastie makers like the Tefal Snack Collection SW852D61 Multi-Function Sandwich and Snack Maker. It is a French company, but it sells its product in different countries, including Australia.

Sunbeam

This is also another household appliance company that is popular in Australia. It makes reliable sandwich presses and other kitchen appliances, making it one of the go-to options.

Features to Look for When Buying Sandwich and Toastie Makers

Non-stick plates

The design of the cooking plates on your toastie maker will determine the type of results that you will get. Non-stick plates are highly preferred because they can cook toasties at high temperatures without the food sticking onto the surface of the plates. Also, they are easier to clean.

Most non-stick cooking plates are ceramic or Teflon coated. Both materials deliver good results, so you can go for either.

Hinge design

The upper and lower parts of a sandwich maker are held in place by a hinge that allows you to clamp the pieces of bread and fillings between the cooking plates. Units with a floating hinge design like the Russell Hobbs RHSP801RED Sandwich Press can accommodate toasties of various thicknesses.

This feature is often overlooked by most people, but it is important that you take it into consideration if you know that you will be making large toasties.

Heat up time

The time taken for the cooking plates to heat up is determined by the power of the heating element. This can be measured in watts. A standard toastie maker can have a wattage rating of 700W to 2,100W. Generally, appliances with a high wattage rating tend to heat faster than those with a low rating.

Adjustable temperature setting

Some multi-use toastie makers have variable temperature systems that will enable you to adjust the heat levels accordingly. This feature can come in handy when making cheese toasties since you’ll be able to cook the cheese with exact precision.

Handle design

For your safety, you should only buy toastie makers with sturdily built stay-cool handles. Most brands design toastie makers with easy-grip handles to prevent slippage.

Locking latch

Toastie makers with locking latches are very easy to use since you don’t have to hold down the top whilst the sandwich is cooking. A locking latch is essential because it prevents heat from escaping, thereby allowing the toastie to cook at a consistent temperature.


You may also be interested in:

Last update on 2022-05-26 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Author

Obsessed with technology. Compelled by innovation. We're your home of gadget reviews, technology news and intensive buyers guides. We believe that technology goes far beyond the gadget itself. From groundbreaking technological advancements to quirky gifts and gizmos, we're here to tell you all about the clash between man and machine.

Write A Comment

Order your Lomi todayPay Only $49 deposit*
Order Your SpyraTwo TodayGet a 5% discount when you use code "MRGADGET_5%"
Order Your SpyraTwo TodayGet a 5% discount when you use code "MRGADGET_5%"
Order your Lomi todayPay Only $49 deposit*
Capture the best Australian Tech deals.
Capture the best Australian tech deals.

Subscribe for the latest deals from Australia's best tech retailers and beyond.